The best horror TV shows for a small dose of scares are anthologies, where one episode tells one complete story and then lets you go to bed: Inside No. 9, the old BBC ghost stories for Christmas, the Creepshow revival and Are You Afraid of the Dark. A horror film wants two hours of your nerve, and some evenings I've only got about twenty five minutes of it in me, which is exactly why I reach for television instead of film on a Tuesday night.
What are the best horror TV shows for a small scare?
Anthology shows are doing most of the work here. One story, one set of characters, one nasty little twist, and then it's over and nobody's asking you to remember six seasons of lore. Inside No. 9 is the one I mention most, because it never plays fair and you genuinely cannot guess where a given episode is going to land. The old BBC ghost stories for Christmas are another favourite, all fog and candlelight and a man in a tweed jacket slowly realising he's made a terrible mistake. And if you want something with a bit more bite and colour to it, the newer Creepshow revival does exactly what the title promises, in short, satisfying doses that feel like flicking through an old horror comic.
I'll also put in a word for Are You Afraid of the Dark, which I watched as a child through my fingers and have since revisited as an adult through slightly fewer fingers. It's gentler than anything else on this list, but there's something about a story told round a campfire that still works on me at thirty-odd.
Advertisement
Why is an anthology better than one long, sprawling story on a school night?
The trouble with a series like The Haunting of Hill House, brilliant as it is, is that it wants a proper weekend. You can't dip into episode six of a slow-burn family haunting and expect to feel anything except confused. An anthology has no such demands. Each episode resolves itself, so there's no dread hanging over you about what you've forgotten by the time you come back to it, which matters more to me than I'd like to admit, because my memory for plot details is roughly the same as my memory for where I left my keys.
There's also something to be said for the format matching the mood. Spooky season doesn't need one enormous, draining story. It needs lots of small, sharp ones, spread across a month of dark evenings, so the fright stays a treat rather than turning into homework.
The bit that actually makes the small dose work
None of this works if you're perched on the edge of the sofa half dressed for outside. The whole point of a twenty five minute horror episode is that it fits into an evening that's otherwise entirely about being warm. I have become borderline evangelical about a proper Chunky knit throw blanket for this exact purpose, the sort you can disappear into up to the chin, because there's a particular kind of bravery that only exists when you know you can hide under something within half a second if it all gets too much.
So that's my actual answer, not a padded-out top twenty, just the shows I put on when I want a proper scare that fits in a normal evening. Anthology first, one story at a time, blanket within reach. It's not a system I'd defend in an argument, but it's worked for every October so far.
Ad · Includes affiliate links; we may earn a commission.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How the links work.