Most "best Halloween films" lists lean on found footage titles and costume-party comedies dressed up as horror, and neither earns a spot on my actual Halloween night. What I put on instead is older and shorter: Halloween 1978, Rosemary's Baby and the Scream films, watched from the sofa with a blanket and a cold coffee I forgot about twenty minutes ago, pulling a face like I've bitten into something sour at everything else on those lists.
Which Halloween films are the most overrated?
Top of my list of grievances is anything shot entirely on a wobbling handheld camera. I know found footage has its fans and I know it's meant to feel real, but three minutes in and I'm not scared, I'm faintly seasick, squinting at a dark corridor wondering if the flickering is meant to be tension or just a bad transfer. It's the one horror trick that takes me completely out of the film instead of into it.
Second complaint: the amount of costume-party comedies that get filed under "horror" the moment October rolls round. They're fine as films. They are not what I mean when I say I want something to watch after dark with the lights down. A talking pumpkin and a laugh track do not a scary night make, and I resent that they take up a slot on the list that could have gone to something with actual atmosphere.
Advertisement
Third, and I'll take the argument if anyone wants it: some of the so-called classics have not aged the way people pretend they have. A film can be important and also, honestly, a bit of a slog forty minutes in. I'm allowed to respect what something did for the genre and still check my phone once during the second act.
What should you actually watch on Halloween night?
If you want mine, properly, here's where I'd start:
- For the one everyone should already own, there's no substitute for the original: the Halloween 1978 Blu-ray box set is still the one I reach for first, because it knows exactly how little it needs to show you to make you nervous.
- For something with a bit more dread and a lot more restraint, Rosemary's Baby 4K restoration is the film I put on when I want to be unsettled slowly rather than jumped at.
- And when I want the room to laugh nervously between the scary bits, the Scream Blu-ray box set still does that better than almost anything made since.
None of these need the lights fully off or the volume up loud. They just need you paying attention, which is more than I can say for half the films that keep getting recommended to me.
The night itself matters more than the list
Honestly, half of what makes a Halloween film work for me isn't the film at all, it's the state I'm in when I press play. Jumper on, something warm in hand, the sort of evening where the warm pumpkin string lights are doing more emotional work than the actual soundtrack. Last year I tried to do the whole thing properly with a carved pumpkin and a good autumn scented candle going, and set the candle too close to the curtain, which was its own small horror film for about four seconds. Nobody was hurt. The curtain has forgiven me. Mostly.
So if you've been handed the same five films every October and quietly wondered why they don't land for you either, you're not wrong and you're not alone. Ranking Halloween films properly means being honest about which ones actually get under your skin and which ones just get repeated because everyone else repeats them. I'll take the atmosphere over the algorithm every time, and a night that's actually mine over someone else's idea of a scary evening.
Ad · Includes affiliate links; we may earn a commission.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How the links work.