My favourite horror anthology movies for Halloween night are Creepshow, Trick 'r Treat, the original Tales from the Crypt films and the V/H/S series, each one swapping in a new story every fifteen minutes rather than asking you to sit through one two-hour build. That's exactly what you want if you've typed "horror anthology movies" into Google at half past nine on a Friday, mug of hot chocolate balanced on the arm of the sofa, jumper sleeves pulled over your hands, because you cannot face committing to a single film all evening.
Halloween night is not the night for a slow-burn film that only pays off in the last ten minutes. It is the night for something that scares you, lets you go and make more toast, then scares you again with an entirely different plot and cast.
Why an anthology is the right call for the night itself
There is a quiet myth that anthology films are the lesser cousin of a "proper" horror film, the one made when nobody could stretch a single idea to feature length. I think it is the other way round. A short segment has to earn its scare in fifteen minutes flat, no room to hide behind atmosphere alone, so the ones that work tend to be the sharpest, nastiest little stories in the genre. And on a night when the doorbell keeps going for trick-or-treaters, or you are half watching while carving a pumpkin badly, an anthology forgives you for looking away. Miss five minutes of one segment and you have lost nothing from the next.
Advertisement
It also solves the actual argument of the evening, which is never really about horror at all, it is about nobody agreeing on one film. An anthology is four or five different films wearing one coat. Everybody gets something.
What are the best horror anthology movies for Halloween night?
Creepshow is where I always start, because it looks like a comic book come to life and it was written with Stephen King, so the stories have that nasty little fairground twist to them. Trick 'r Treat is the proper Halloween one, five stories tangled together in one small town on the night itself, which feels appropriate for exactly this occasion. If you want something a bit rougher round the edges, the original Tales from the Crypt films have aged into something genuinely fun rather than dated, and the V/H/S series is worth it if you like your horror shot like a found tape somebody really should not have found.
None of these need a long commitment or a lecture beforehand about what you are about to watch. You put one on, you make a decision about the next segment based purely on the title, and you carry on with your evening.
Setting the scene before anyone presses play
I am fairly convinced the film matters less than the room it is watched in, which sounds like something I have made up to justify buying candles, and it probably is. Lamps off, one small light on somewhere so nobody trips over the coffee table, and something warm to drink that is not going to spill everywhere the first time something jumps out. I have a set of warm pumpkin string lights along the shelf for exactly this, low enough not to compete with the telly but enough that the room does not feel like a cinema that has forgotten to turn the big lights back on. Add a chunky knit throw blanket over your knees and you have built yourself a proper defensive position for whatever comes out of the television.
If you would rather skip the individual hunting about and just own a set of classics for nights like this, a Classic horror 4K box set earns its shelf space far quicker than most things I own.
The bit where I admit I fell asleep
Last October I fell asleep halfway through a segment I had already seen twice, woke up during a completely different story with a completely different cast, and spent a confused thirty seconds wondering if I had somehow put the wrong disc in. That is the beauty of the format. Nobody paused it for me, nothing was ruined, and I picked the thread back up as if nothing had happened. Try that with a two hour ghost story and see how far you get.
So that is my answer, properly, plainly: for Halloween night specifically, reach for the anthology. Put the kettle on between segments, keep the lights low and the throw close, and let one small disaster in a short story be somebody else's problem for fifteen minutes at a time.
Ad · Includes affiliate links; we may earn a commission.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How the links work.