The Black Cat is the Poe story that still feels genuinely cruel

Ad · Includes affiliate links; we may earn a commission.

If you've typed "the black cat poe" into a search bar, you're probably after one of two things: what actually happens in it, or why it's stuck with you since school in a way the other one, the one with the heart under the floorboards, somehow didn't. I've spent the last week living with this story again, because it's going out as the weekly reading on the channel over Halloween weekend, the 30th, and I want to talk about why it's the one I dread doing more than any of the others on the list.

The plot, if you need the reminder: a man who describes himself, quite calmly, as having once been a gentle and humane sort of person, develops a taste for drink, and takes that taste out on his cat. There's a mutilation early on that I won't dress up, an act of cruelty done half in spite and half in shame at his own cruelty, which is somehow the worse motive of the two. Then a second cat arrives, eerily like the first, and the story tightens around the narrator until it ends the way you probably remember it ending, badly, and with a wall involved.

Why the black cat Poe wrote is still the cruel one

The Tell-Tale Heart gets all the attention, and I understand why: it's tidy, it's a single escalating panic, and the ending lands like a trapdoor. But nobody in that story does anything to deserve what happens to them except be old and have an unsettling eye. The black cat Poe gives us is different, because the violence in it isn't random and it isn't supernatural pretending to be the point. It's a man explaining, in reasonable sentences, how he came to do an unreasonable thing to something that trusted him. He even has a word for it, a horrible, useful word: perverseness, the urge to do wrong precisely because you know it's wrong. That's not a ghost story mechanism. That's just how people actually fail each other, dressed up in a coat with a raven on the cover. I read it the first time thinking it would be about a haunted animal, and it isn't, not really. The cat is barely the villain of it. He is.

I'm not someone who investigates noises, as anyone who's followed me for more than a week will know, but this is the one Poe story that makes me go and check on my own cat mid-read, just to look at her being unbothered and asleep on the good blanket, because the alternative is sitting with what the narrator does and calling it entertainment.

Reading it out loud changes it

Doing the weekly reading has taught me something I didn't expect, which is that a story you've only ever read silently behaves differently once you have to say the cruel bits out loud. There's a paragraph in the middle where the narrator justifies himself, and reading it in my own voice, at my own kitchen table, with the kettle just switched off, felt uncomfortably like being talked round by someone I should absolutely not be listening to. That's the version going out on the channel this Halloween weekend: the full text, nothing trimmed for pacing, because trimming it would be doing the narrator's job for him, tidying up a man who very much does not deserve tidying.

If you want the atmosphere without the discomfort of my kitchen acoustics, there's a proper reading of it and a few of its stablemates in this Short ghost story collection, which sits by the good chair for exactly this kind of night, and it earns its space there because half the stories in it do the same trick Poe does: ordinary people, one bad decision, no monster required.

What to read alongside it if you're in the mood

If The Black Cat has got its hooks in you the way it's got into mine this week, the natural next step isn't more Poe straight away, it's a break to let the nastiness settle, then back in with something that shares its DNA. I keep a proper Dracula classic novel hardback on the shelf for exactly this kind of restless reading mood, not because the two stories are alike, but because both understand that a monster is far less interesting than a person who's decided cruelty is reasonable.

And if, like me, this is the week you finally admit you want the collected stories properly bound rather than read off a cracked phone screen at midnight, a Frankenstein Mary Shelley hardback classic makes a fair companion piece for the same shelf: another story about a creator who does something unforgivable and then spends the rest of the book explaining why it felt necessary at the time. Poe's narrator would recognise the tone immediately.

The reading goes up Halloween weekend. I'd tell you to watch it with the lights off for atmosphere, but honestly, after spending this long inside that man's head, I'll be leaving every lamp in the flat on.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.