Cosy horror for dark nights

Same nightmares. Different stories.

Film · 2023

Five Nights at Freddy's

A troubled security guard takes the night shift at a derelict pizzeria and works out its mascots aren't just old wiring.

Five Nights at Freddy's, an After Dark title card
Year
2023
Directed by
Emma Tammi
Starring
Josh Hutcherson, Elizabeth Lail, Mary Stuart Masterson, Matthew Lillard, Piper Rubio, MatPat, CoryxKenshin, Theodus Crane
Running time
109 minutes
Country
United States
Original language
English
Kind of horror
Ghost, Possession, Isolation

Picture the worst job listing you've ever seen: overnight security guard at a pizzeria nobody has bothered to fix up since the animatronics stopped being cute. That's the job Josh Hutcherson takes on here, because sometimes rent doesn't care how creaky the floorboards are or how few exits there seem to be.

It doesn't take long before he works out those furry mascots aren't just old wiring and bad puppetry. Something is still in there, and it hasn't clocked off in years. The horror creeps rather than jumps, at least at first, which is somehow worse, and the pizzeria keeps its secrets close for a good while yet.

Emma Tammi directs it with a proper eye for a building that used to be full of children's laughter and now just echoes, which is its own kind of unsettling even before anything moves that shouldn't.

This is one for the people who like their scares to come with a mystery attached, the sort of night where you want the lights half on and a friend within shouting distance. Don't expect answers early. Do expect to look twice at anything wearing a costume for a while afterwards.

If you like this, try

Film · 2025

28 Years Later

A boy who has never known anything else must get his ill mother to help, decades after Britain's outbreak began.

Film · 2018

A Quiet Place

A family must live in near total silence to survive creatures that hunt by sound alone.

Film · 1979

Alien

A commercial crew answers a distress call and finds they are not alone on their own ship.

Film · 2019

Annabelle Comes Home

The doll comes back into the Warrens' world for a long and difficult night.

Join the Club, free

The After Dark Top 40

Forty horror films counted down like the charts, from silent classics to new favourites, picked by Erin and sent the moment you join.