Cosy horror for dark nights

Same nightmares. Different stories.

Film · 2017

Annabelle: Creation

The doll's whole sorry history starts here, well before anyone thought to give her to a child.

Annabelle: Creation, an After Dark title card
Year
2017
Directed by
David F. Sandberg
Starring
Miranda Otto, Stephanie Sigman, Talitha Bateman, Philippa Coulthard, Grace Fulton, Anthony LaPaglia, Adam Bartley, Lotta Losten
Running time
109 minutes
Country
United States
Original language
English
Kind of horror
Haunted house, Possession, Gothic

Before Annabelle ever ended up in someone's spare room causing chaos, she had to come from somewhere, and this is that somewhere. David F. Sandberg takes the doll right back to her beginnings, in a house that's already carrying more grief than any house should have to. Something in that house has been waiting for an opening, and a doll is exactly the sort of quiet, patient thing that can offer one.

This is proper creeping dread rather than one big shock. Long corridors, things left slightly wrong in a room, that horrible doll-in-the-corner stare. It builds rather than dumps everything on you at once, though there's still plenty here to make you regret checking on a noise.

Watch it on a night when you want to be unsettled without needing therapy afterwards. It's part of the wider Conjuring world, so if you've enjoyed any of that, this fills in a piece you didn't know you wanted filled in. Not one for anyone who already sleeps with the landing light on.

If you like this, try

Film · 2017

Get Out

A young man's visit to meet his girlfriend's family curdles into something far stranger than nerves.

Film · 2025

Obsession

A wish for love turns a music-store clerk's friend into something far more dangerous than a crush.

Film · 2003

Saw

Two strangers wake up chained in a filthy bathroom, playing a killer's twisted game with no idea why.

Film · 2016

The Conjuring 2

The Warrens go to England to help a family living with a poltergeist in their council house.

Join the Club, free

The After Dark Top 40

Forty horror films counted down like the charts, from silent classics to new favourites, picked by Erin and sent the moment you join.