Cosy horror for dark nights

Same nightmares. Different stories.

TV series · 2011

American Horror Story

An anthology series that starts its story fresh with a new setting and cast each season.

American Horror Story, an After Dark title card
Year
2011
Created by
Ryan Murphy, Brad Falchuk
Starring
Connie Britton, Dylan McDermott, Evan Peters, Taissa Farmiga, Denis O'Hare, Jessica Lange, Zachary Quinto, Joseph Fiennes
Seasons
13
Episodes
132
Network
FX
Country
United States
Original language
English
Kind of horror
Psychological, Gothic

This is the show that refuses to just carry on. Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk built it so each run is its own sealed story, a new set of people dropped into a new nightmare, with only a shared universe humming underneath to tell you it is still the same show.

That structure does something clever to the dread. You never get comfortable, because the rules of what frightens you are being rewritten every time you come back. Some strands lean on real, half remembered history, which gives the fear a colder, more familiar edge than a purely invented monster ever manages.

It runs long enough that there is always another season waiting once one world has finished with you, each one its own beginning, middle and end rather than a single story dragged out.

It suits a night when you want to be unsettled rather than soothed, ideally with the lights down low and nothing pressing to do straight after.

If you like this, try

TV series · 1955

Alfred Hitchcock Presents

Alfred Hitchcock's own anthology of dramas, thrillers and mysteries, one twisty little tale after another.

TV series · 2021

American Horror Stories

An anthology from the American Horror Story team, a fresh horror story in nearly every episode.

TV series · 1999

Angel

A supernatural drama spun off from Buffy the Vampire Slayer, with horror, action and fantasy in the mix.

TV series · 2013

Bates Motel

A psychological horror drama imagining the earlier lives of the Bates family, drawn from Robert Bloch's Psycho, across five seasons on A&E.

Join the Club, free

The After Dark Top 40

Forty horror films counted down like the charts, from silent classics to new favourites, picked by Erin and sent the moment you join.