The order to watch this year's classic horror anniversaries in is simple: Nosferatu first, then Carrie and The Omen, then Scream to close the night. Every one of these is having some kind of birthday this year, but the birthday isn't really the point, it's just the excuse to finally book the evening in.
Putting Scream before Nosferatu is like eating the dessert before anyone's had a starter. It works, technically, but it's not a proper night in. So here's the running order I'd actually use, birthdays included.
Which classic horror film should you watch first?
Nosferatu is well over a century old now, silent, in black and white, and it's the film every other one on this list owes something to, whether they'd admit it or not. Watching it first does two things: it sets a slow, patient pace for the evening, and it makes you appreciate how much of modern horror is just Nosferatu's tricks with better lighting. Don't watch a scratchy upload with terrible subtitles as your first go at it — I did, and nearly gave up after ten minutes. A Nosferatu 1922 restored Blu-ray is a far kinder way in, and it means the first film of the night actually looks the way it was meant to.
Advertisement
Move into Carrie and The Omen once everyone's settled
This is where the night gets properly uncomfortable, on purpose. Carrie and The Omen both came out in 1976, and both work the same way: no jump scares, just dread that's allowed to sit there until you're the one who's too calm about things, checking the landing before bed. Carrie does it through a school gym and an overbearing mother; The Omen does it through a child who's a bit too calm about everything. Play them back to back and the two feed off each other — one small-town, one global, both about the same fear of something being quietly wrong with someone close to you. A Classic horror 4K box set is the easiest way to have both ready to go rather than hunting round streaming libraries at ten at night, which I have also done, and also regretted.
Which film should you finish the night with?
By the time you get to Scream, thirty this year, everyone in the room has spent two films being told to stay quiet and take it seriously. Scream breaks that on purpose: the characters have all seen the same films the audience has, they know the rules, and it doesn't make anyone safer. It's faster, funnier, and a lot louder than anything that's come before it in the running order, which is exactly why it works as the closer rather than the opener. I still find the phone ringing the single most stressful sound in horror, and I've seen this one enough times to know better by now. A Scream Blu-ray box set is worth having on the shelf if this is becoming a yearly thing, rather than relying on whatever happens to be streaming.
Why does the order matter more than the anniversaries?
Swap this running order around and the night doesn't land the same way. Open with Scream and Nosferatu feels glacial by comparison. Open with Carrie and The Omen and you've peaked too early, with nowhere left for the dread to go. Slow, then dreadful, then loud is the shape that actually works for a shared watch, and it's the same shape whether or not any of the films happen to be having a big anniversary. The birthdays are just this year's reason to finally get round to it.
So that's the plan: Nosferatu to open, Carrie and The Omen for the middle, Scream to send everyone home able to sleep. Put the kettle on, get the room settled before the first film starts, and let a hundred years of classic horror do the rest.
Ad · Includes affiliate links; we may earn a commission.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How the links work.